WWF Puerto Rico 1985: The Expansion That Failed

Rain began pouring into Hiram Bithorn Stadium while Hulk Hogan defended the WWF Championship against Big John Studd on October 19, 1985. By then, the WWF Puerto Rico show was already in trouble. The weather made the WWF footage memorable, but the storm was only one part of the failure. Vince McMahon’s expanding company had entered a market with its own stars, television presence, promotional relationships, and an intensely loyal audience. Puerto Rico answered before the first drop of rain reached the ring.

Vince McMahon’s WWF Expansion Reaches Puerto Rico

By 1985, the WWF’s national expansion was in full gear. Vince McMahon had secured television clearances outside the company’s traditional northeastern base, signed prominent wrestlers from rival organizations, and staged the first WrestleMania at Madison Square Garden on March 31.

Hulk Hogan stood at the center of that transformation. At the same time, McMahon’s WWF machine kept pulling talent from Mid-South Wrestling, Jim Crockett Promotions, and especially the American Wrestling Association as it consolidated many of wrestling’s leading attractions under one banner.

Although the immediate focus was the continental United States and Canada, this was only the first step in McMahon’s larger plan. He spoke openly of wanting to become the "Walt Disney of wrestling," building a national entertainment company that could move beyond the territory system’s regional boundaries.

Puerto Rico, however, was not an unclaimed market. Carlos Colón, Victor Jovica, and their partners had built Capitol Sports Promotions and the World Wrestling Council into the island’s dominant wrestling operation. Local television supported regular live events, while Colón had become the promotion’s central attraction and one of Puerto Rico’s most recognizable wrestlers.

Carlos Colón was therefore more than the leading name on a wrestling card. As a wrestler, promoter, and owner, he represented the established business that the visiting WWF show threatened to bypass.

Gorilla Monsoon’s WWC Ownership in Puerto Rico

Puerto Rico also had an internal connection to one of the WWF’s backstage power brokers: Gorilla Monsoon.

In Brian R. Solomon’s Irresistible Force: The Life and Times of Gorilla Monsoon, Solomon wrote that Monsoon held a 10 percent interest in the Puerto Rican promotion alongside Colón and Jovica. Monsoon had also been one of the stakeholders in the WWWF under Vince McMahon Sr., and his secure position with the company became increasingly valuable as McMahon’s national expansion gathered momentum.

By 1984, Monsoon no longer needed his Puerto Rican interest as a safety net. That was not the only reason he considered giving it up. According to Solomon, his relationship with Colón and Jovica had soured, particularly over payments.

"Gino was a 10 percent owner, and yet he hadn’t been seeing anything," Solomon wrote.

As a result, Monsoon transferred his stake to his protégé, Victor Quiñones. Monsoon had taken the young Quiñones under his wing, and the ownership interest gave his protégé a foothold in the wrestling business.

The transfer ended Monsoon’s formal ownership interest while leaving his longstanding personal relationships with Quiñones, Colón, and Jovica intact.

Inside the WWF Puerto Rico 1985 Bought Show

That history made it all the more problematic when WWF executive Jim Troy arranged a Puerto Rican event with a local promoter who was not affiliated with WWC. According to Solomon, the agreement was completed without Monsoon first having the opportunity to consult his former business partners.

From a business standpoint, the move appeared to be a no-brainer. "The event was set up as a ‘bought show,’ in which a local promoter would pay Titan [the WWF’s parent company at the time] a set fee for branding and the talent, then handle all the ticket sales, where the promoter would hopefully make their money back," Solomon wrote.

The show could expand the WWF’s reach and potentially open the door to another market. If it did not work, Titan Sports had already secured its fee, leaving the local promoter responsible for advertising, ticket sales, and the financial result. The risk was largely outsourced.

But Monsoon still had a personal interest in WWC and longstanding relationships with Colón, Jovica, and especially Quiñones. The deal had been made before he could discuss possible cooperation with the people controlling the island’s leading promotion.

Monsoon also understood that Puerto Rico was unlike the mainland territories the WWF had entered. "Invading anyone else’s territory was a dicey proposition, but in Puerto Rico, it could be particularly dangerous, and [Monsoon] knew that," Solomon wrote.

Our wrestling history is gold, and so are readers like you!

If you are enjoying this story, here is how you can support us:

Join our newsletter! Leave a tip Browse our merch

WWC Answers with Battle of the Gladiators

But the deal was made, and the date was set for October 19, 1985, at the outdoor Hiram Bithorn Stadium in San Juan. To nobody’s surprise, WWC reacted quickly by booking its own opposition show less than ten miles away at Juan Ramón Loubriel Stadium in Bayamón.

WWC built Battle of the Gladiators around the stars its audience already knew. Colón faced Abdullah the Butcher for the vacant WWC Universal Heavyweight Championship, while the Invaders, José González and Johnny Rivera, defended the WWC World Tag Team Championship against Nikita and Ivan Koloff.

The visiting Koloffs were closely associated with Jim Crockett Promotions, one of McMahon’s major mainland competitors. Their appearance illustrated how WWC could supplement its local roster with recognizable international talent rather than conceding the date to the WWF.

The principal attractions were clear: Colón against Abdullah, with the Invaders facing the Koloffs.

Before the competing events, Monsoon reportedly met with Colón to lower the temperature. He described the WWF appearance as a one-time special attraction rather than the beginning of an invasion comparable to what was happening on the mainland. The event would be recorded for later use, but the explanation did not prevent WWC from running its opposition show.

Hulk Hogan and Big John Studd Wrestle in the Rain

When bell time came, only around 1,200 fans reportedly found their way into Hiram Bithorn Stadium. Graham Cawthon’s The History of Professional Wrestling, Volume 1: WWF 1963-1989 and Cagematch use the same estimate. A January 17, 2005 report in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter later rounded the crowd to 2,000.

The Municipality of San Juan lists Hiram Bithorn Stadium’s standard capacity at 18,000, although the exact seating configuration and number of tickets offered for the 1985 wrestling event have not been established. Even using the higher estimate of 2,000, the reported turnout represented only about 11 percent of that capacity.

Whatever the exact figure, the stadium was largely empty. The WWF had brought Hulk Hogan, Wendi Richter with Cyndi Lauper, Randy Savage, Tito Santana, Ricky Steamboat, Tony Atlas, Pedro Morales, the Killer Bees, and several other established names, but the lineup could not overcome WWC’s local advantage.

The eight-match card began with Tony Atlas defeating Steve Lombardi in 5:45. Corporal Kirchner beat Tiger Chung Lee in 7:05, Ricky Steamboat defeated Moondog Spot in 4:28, and WWF Women’s Champion Wendi Richter retained against the Spider Lady in 6:06.

Gorilla Monsoon worked double duty as commentator and ring announcer. The surviving presentation required him to call the action, introduce the participants, announce the decisions, and manage the broadcast position without a regular commentary partner.

Watch the Full WWF Puerto Rico 1985 Show

The surviving recording preserves the complete eight-match WWF card from Hiram Bithorn Stadium. What begins as an unusual outdoor presentation changes dramatically during Hulk Hogan’s championship defense against Big John Studd, but the wrestlers, officials, and Gorilla Monsoon still have three matches left to complete as the conditions deteriorate.

Every recorded match ended with the wrestler positioned as the crowd favorite winning. Some later accounts speculated that the sweep was designed either to satisfy the audience or reduce the risk of trouble, but no reliable source establishes why the WWF booked those finishes.

The event itself soon became a dreary occasion. Rain reached the stadium during Hulk Hogan’s WWF Championship defense against Big John Studd, soaking the exposed ring and making normal movement increasingly difficult. Fans opened umbrellas around ringside, while others moved in search of shelter.

Hogan against Studd was the fifth match rather than the final bout. Rain intensified as Hogan made his comeback during their 7:22 contest. Studd went outside, the referee counted him out, and Hogan retained without scoring a pinfall.

The WWF did not stop the show. The Killer Bees defeated Iron Mike Sharpe and Barry O in 4:10 as water collected on the canvas. That match later appeared on the November 5, 1985 edition of Prime Time Wrestling and on The Best of the WWF, Volume 16.

As the Killer Bees, Tito Santana, and Randy Savage tried to work on the slippery surface, Monsoon sat at the broadcast position with plastic covering him and the equipment. Solomon described him chain-smoking as the rain disrupted the production around him.

The rain eased somewhat as Santana and Savage continued their Intercontinental Championship match, but the damage had been done. Footage showed the wrestlers reducing their movement and struggling for secure footing as the canvas became increasingly slick. Santana retained with a small package after 8:08.

Local hero Pedro Morales then faced The Spoiler in the last match of the night. Their contest lasted only 1:14, with Morales winning by small package and bringing the rain-soaked event to an abrupt end.

Meanwhile, less than ten miles away, WWC reportedly drew 15,000 fans to Battle of the Gladiators. Colón defeated Abdullah the Butcher for the vacant WWC Universal Heavyweight Championship, while the Invaders retained their tag team title against Ivan and Nikita Koloff.

The results were in: the WWF’s attempt to run a show in Puerto Rico on its own had failed. Rain made the footage memorable, but it did not cause thousands of fans to choose the rival stadium before the storm began.

With hundreds of amazing Pro Wrestling Stories to dive into, where do you start? Get the inside scoop, join our exclusive community of wrestling fans! Receive 10 hand-picked stories curated just for YOU, exclusive weekly content, and an instant welcome gift when you sign up today!

Jim Troy and the Alleged Post-Show Warning

The weather and attendance were not the only reasons the 1985 trip acquired such a troubling reputation inside the WWF. In the January 17, 2005 edition of Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Dave Meltzer reported what he described as "an alleged incident" involving the executive who headed the company’s international events at the time:

"Worse, a major company executive who headed the international shows at the time was kidnapped after the show."

Meltzer further alleged that a firearm was placed to the executive’s head and that he was warned a future return would involve a loaded one. The Observer did not identify the executive, but Brian R. Solomon’s later biography identified him as Jim Troy.

The story resurfaced two decades later on the January 16, 2025, episode of Grilling JR. After host Conrad Thompson recounted Meltzer’s report and asked whether Troy had been the executive, Jim Ross replied, "I think it was," before adding, "Sounds familiar."

Troy remained with the WWF for several more years. His tenure ended after a physical altercation with Koko B. Ware in a hotel lobby during the company’s 1989 European tour.

The WWF did not follow the San Juan event with another stand-alone Puerto Rican stadium campaign. When it eventually returned to the market, the company took a very different approach.

Back to Puerto Rico: WWF and IWA Begin Their 1999 Partnership

By the late 1990s, WWF alumni Savio Vega and Miguel Pérez Jr., along with Gorilla Monsoon’s protégé Victor Quiñones, had become central figures in the International Wrestling Association. IWA emerged as a direct competitor to WWC and, especially in its early years, relied heavily on its relationship with the WWF.

The WWF returned to Puerto Rico through its relationship with IWA in February 1999. The February 22, 1999 edition of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter recorded joint IWA and WWF cards in Carolina on February 11 and Ponce on February 12.

The touring roster included Val Venis, Al Snow, Goldust, Edge, Gangrel, Luna Vachon, Jacqueline, Taka Michinoku, Dick Togo, the Legion of Doom, and wrestlers associated with the WWF’s Spanish-language Super Astros program.

This time, the WWF entered through cooperation rather than confrontation. Working with Quiñones and IWA gave the company access to local knowledge, promotional relationships, buildings, and an audience already familiar with the people organizing the events.

The relationship eventually grew beyond occasional talent appearances. The January 17, 2005 edition of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter retrospectively described IWA as having served as a WWF developmental territory.

By 2002, however, the arrangement was ending. The September 2, 2002 edition of the Observer reported that WWE had withdrawn its talent and stopped using IWA in that capacity.

IWA continued competing against Colón and Jovica’s WWC after the partnership ended. The relationship also established a new model for the WWF in Puerto Rico. Rather than attempting another stand-alone entry like the failed 1985 event, the company returned by cooperating with an organization that already understood the island’s wrestling business.

WWE Returns for New Year’s Revolution 2005

On January 9, 2005, WWE finally presented another major stand-alone Puerto Rican event under its own banner. New Year’s Revolution took place inside the Coliseo de Puerto Rico José Miguel Agrelot in San Juan, almost twenty years after the rain-soaked stadium show.

Memories and perceptions of the earlier trip remained part of the preparation. The Wrestling Observer Newsletter reported that WWE personnel received a memo instructing them not to leave the hotel area. The newsletter connected the company’s apprehension to the alleged 1985 incident, concerns about past crowd behavior, and the circumstances surrounding Bruiser Brody’s passing in Puerto Rico in 1988.

Jim Ross discussed that precaution on a January 2025 episode of Grilling JR. "I endorsed it," Ross said of the instruction to remain at the hotel. He explained that the property contained restaurants and a large casino, giving WWE personnel access to what they needed during a trip that he remembered as lasting only about two nights. His recollection showed how strongly the company’s concerns persisted nearly twenty years after the 1985 event.

The business result bore no resemblance to 1985. The Wrestling Observer Newsletter reported a sellout of 15,764 and a final gate of approximately $825,000. An earlier estimate above $1 million had counted every distributed ticket, including approximately 2,000 complimentary admissions.

The pay-per-view was built around an Elimination Chamber match for the vacant World Heavyweight Championship. Triple H defeated Randy Orton, Batista, Chris Benoit, Chris Jericho, and Edge to regain the title, with Shawn Michaels serving as special guest referee.

Nonetheless, the event produced another night of physical disruption. The first two televised matches resulted in serious knee injuries. Eugene injured his left knee during the World Tag Team Championship match, forcing an early finish, while Lita tore her anterior cruciate ligament against Trish Stratus.

Vince McMahon also met with Colón and Jovica of WWC and with Quiñones of IWA. According to the Observer, McMahon told representatives of the rival promotions that WWE did not intend to take sides in their local competition.

After the success of New Year’s Revolution, WWE returned for several house shows and made Puerto Rico a recurring stop on its touring schedule. Later database entries place attendance for individual dates between 7,000 and 18,000, though these historical figures remain estimates unless supported by ticket records.

Backlash 2023 Sets Puerto Rico Gate Records

Another major televised WWE event arrived on May 6, 2023. Backlash returned to the Coliseo de Puerto Rico with international music star and Puerto Rican native Bad Bunny facing Damian Priest in a San Juan Street Fight.

The match became a celebration of Puerto Rican wrestling as much as a celebrity attraction. Savio Vega and Carlito both appeared, connecting the modern event to the island’s wrestling history and the WWF’s earlier relationship with IWA.

WWE announced 17,944 attendees for Backlash and 16,896 for the previous evening’s SmackDown. The company described Backlash as its largest gate in Puerto Rico and the highest-grossing Backlash to that point.

Records obtained from the Puerto Rico Convention Center District Authority supplied more precise business figures. Backlash sold 15,145 tickets, issued another 1,351 complimentary admissions, and generated $1,447,558 in gate revenue. SmackDown sold 14,282 tickets and produced a $1,048,295 gate.

The difference between announced attendance and paid attendance did not diminish the scale of the weekend. WWE filled the arena on consecutive nights and built its featured match around Puerto Rican performers, music, history, and audience identification rather than presenting the island as an anonymous stop on a national tour.

In December 2025, POST Wrestling reported that WWE was planning to bring Backlash back to San Juan on May 9, 2026. The report cited multiple sources, including one with access to an internal WWE calendar, but the company never publicly announced Puerto Rico as the host.

POST Wrestling noted that WWE’s 2023 weekend received a $1.5 million subsidy and a further $300,000 in-kind contribution from the Puerto Rico Convention District Authority. The outlet could not establish whether comparable incentives were available for 2026, and local government officials did not respond to its requests for comment.

On January 31, 2026, Triple H announced that Backlash would instead take place at Benchmark International Arena in Tampa. POST Wrestling subsequently sought clarification about the change but reported no explanation from WWE.

A return in 2026 would have brought Backlash back to San Juan only three years after the record-setting 2023 weekend and would have established Puerto Rico as a recurring destination for WWE’s biggest events rather than an occasional special attraction.

Instead, the reported plan disappeared from the calendar without a public explanation. Puerto Rico had already demonstrated that it could deliver the audience, atmosphere, and revenue WWE wanted. Why the anticipated encore never reached the announcement stage remains unanswered.

Why the WWF’s 1985 Puerto Rico Expansion Failed

The WWF Puerto Rico 1985 failure was not simply the product of bad weather. Vince McMahon’s company arrived with many of America’s most recognizable wrestlers, but it entered a market where WWC already possessed television exposure, promotional relationships, trusted local stars, and an audience deeply invested in its product.

WWC’s response exposed the weakness in the WWF’s approach. Thousands of fans chose Carlos Colón, Abdullah the Butcher, the Invaders, and the Koloffs in Bayamón before rain disrupted the event in San Juan. The storm turned a disappointing venture into unforgettable footage, but it did not cause the underlying defeat.

When the company rebuilt its presence in Puerto Rico, it followed a different path. Its relationship with IWA provided local knowledge and established connections, while New Year’s Revolution 2005 and Backlash 2023 recognized Puerto Rico as a major wrestling market with stars, traditions, and an identity of its own.

That became the lasting lesson of the night at Hiram Bithorn Stadium. In 1985, the WWF attempted to impose its national expansion on Puerto Rico from the outside.

Nearly four decades later, WWE achieved the success that had escaped it by building its biggest Puerto Rican event around the culture and audience it had once expected simply to win over. The image that endured was Gorilla Monsoon beneath plastic as rain swallowed the production, but the empty seats told the deeper story: Puerto Rico was never a territory waiting to be conquered.

These stories may also interest you:

• The Strange Case of Manny Fernandez vs. Invader 3
• Savio Vega: Secret History of the Original Boricua
• Pedro Morales: WWE’s Forgotten Champion and Hero