Inside TNA’s 20-Year Fight for Wrestling Glory

In 2002, pro wrestling was in flux. WCW and ECW had folded, and fans craved something new. Enter Jerry and Jeff Jarrett, who launched NWA: Total Nonstop Action (TNA) to fill the void with fast-paced, boundary-pushing action. From weekly PPVs to Spike TV breakthroughs, dive into the wild two-decade saga of triumphs, misfires, moments of boundary-pushing matches, headline-grabbing signings, and a near-impossible gamble. But when did ambition tip into chaos? And, could TNA survive its own audacity? Read on to uncover the twist that changed everything.

Why TNA’s Unconventional PPV Model Shook Up WWE

By 2023, TNA (then Impact Wrestling) had spurred a resurgence in its fan base and solidified its place as the third-largest professional wrestling promotion in the United States.

With a consistent schedule of critically acclaimed live shows and highly anticipated quarterly pay-per-view events, Impact had carved out a loyal audience and proven its staying power in a crowded wrestling market.

But long before this modern resurgence, TNA Wrestling had far more ambitious goals. It wanted to challenge and eventually dethrone WWE as the top wrestling company in the world.

In its early days, TNA aligned itself with the National Wrestling Alliance (NWA), a once-prestigious governing body that had, by the early 2000s, lost much of its mainstream appeal.

Rather than follow the traditional path of securing a television deal upfront, TNA adopted a bold and unconventional model: running weekly pay-per-view events without a TV contract. This innovative approach was risky, but it reflected the company’s belief that a compelling in-ring product would eventually attract major television partners.

And for a time, that gamble paid off.

Despite operating outside the usual system, TNA began to build a dedicated fanbase. Young, dynamic performers like AJ Styles, Christopher Daniels, and Samoa Joe delivered high-caliber matches that earned praise from both fans and critics. The company’s in-ring product was also seen as a breath of fresh air, offering a high-energy, athletic alternative to WWE’s more polished, storyline-heavy programming.

By October 2005, TNA secured a national television deal with Spike TV, a major breakthrough that catapulted the company into mainstream visibility.

With this exposure, TNA rapidly became the most buzzworthy destination for professional wrestlers outside of WWE, an emerging force with the momentum to redefine the wrestling landscape.

How Ex-WWE Stars Fuelled TNA’s Mid-2000s Boom

As TNA gained momentum and began making waves in the wrestling world, the company made a controversial strategic shift that would define much of its mid-2000s identity.

Under the leadership of president Dixie Carter, TNA increasingly turned to ex-WWE talent in an attempt to boost ratings and bolster mainstream recognition. The result was a roster that, over time, became saturated with former WWE stars, often at the expense of the very homegrown talent that had built the company’s reputation from the ground up.

The logic seemed sound: familiar names could attract casual viewers, give legitimacy to the brand, and compete directly with WWE on star power.

But the execution was flawed.

Instead of using ex-WWE wrestlers to elevate TNA originals, many newcomers were immediately pushed to the top of the card, shifting the spotlight away from the promotion’s rising stars.

This growing reliance on former WWE performers was on full display at Victory Road 2007, one of TNA’s marquee pay-per-view events.

The main event featured Kurt Angle teaming with The Dudley Boyz (known in TNA as Team 3D) – all major WWE alumni. Elsewhere on the card were Christian Cage, Rhino, Gail Kim, Tomko, and even a surprise appearance from 1970s WWWF World Champion Bob Backlund.

For fans, the event felt more like a WWE reunion than a showcase of TNA’s unique identity.

Behind the scenes, however, many former WWE wrestlers welcomed the transition to TNA. The reduced travel schedule and centralized operations, primarily at Universal Studios in Orlando, made for a far more relaxed lifestyle than WWE’s relentless global touring.

In a 2007 episode of my show, the PWB Podcast, former WWE Tag Team Champion The Damaja (previously known as Danny Basham) discussed the appeal of TNA’s schedule as he prepared to compete on the Victory Road card, ironically in a match involving more former WWE tag champions.

"The schedule’s a little bit lighter because they don’t tour as much. They don’t run as many shows and have as many dates. Most of their shows – the TV tapings and pay-per-views – are taped out of Orlando. Compared to WWE, which tapes and tours all over the world, TNA was a lot more grounded."

He went on to share his optimism about the company’s future:

"I see them growing even more and expanding even more. Hopefully, the ratings continue to grow, and the buy rates will get higher. Hopefully, they get some more TV time. They need two hours because they’ve got a lot of guys on their roster and on the outside that have talent and need TV time."

For wrestlers seeking stability, TNA was a refreshing alternative.

But for fans who had once championed TNA as a proving ground for fresh, exciting talent, the increasingly WWE-heavy presentation began to feel like a betrayal of what the company originally stood for.

The X-Division Revolution That Redefined Wrestling

Looking back, it’s almost unbelievable that at one point, TNA Wrestling was trying to cram one of the most talent-rich rosters in professional wrestling into a single hour of television each week.

Aside from the secondary show Xplosion, which typically consisted of recaps and highlights, the flagship Impact! broadcast was all they had to showcase a stacked lineup that included Kurt Angle, Sting, AJ Styles, Samoa Joe, Christian Cage, a thriving X-Division, and a highly respected Knockouts division.

That bottleneck of talent finally began to ease in October 2007, when TNA was granted an extra hour of TV time on Spike. This expansion was a critical step toward allowing the company to better showcase its deep roster and complex storylines.

Around the same time, TNA also took a major leap in branding. After years of sharing a legacy with the National Wrestling Alliance, the company officially cut ties with the NWA and retired the NWA-branded titles in favor of their own TNA World Heavyweight and Tag Team Championships. It was a symbolic move. TNA was now fully standing on its own.

Yet 2007 was also a year of strange headlines.

In a decision that baffled wrestling purists and sparked mainstream curiosity, TNA signed NFL cornerback Adam "Pacman" Jones. Recently suspended by the NFL for his involvement in a violent nightclub altercation where someone in his entourage fired a shot into a crowd, Jones was brought into TNA at the height of his notoriety.

However, due to legal restrictions and contractual obligations with the NFL, he was barred from taking part in any physical contact in the ring. Despite that, he was booked to win the TNA Tag Team Championship, an outcome that many viewed as a publicity stunt gone too far.

Still, amid questionable decisions and uneven creative directions, one part of TNA’s identity remained consistently strong: the X-Division.

This high-flying, no-limits division became a defining feature of the promotion. Echoing the fast-paced excitement of WCW’s legendary cruiserweight division, the X-Division prioritized athleticism, speed, and innovation.

As commentator Mike Tenay famously declared: "It’s not about weight limits. It’s about no limits." This philosophy culminated in the creation of the Ultimate X match, an adrenaline-fueled spectacle that became a TNA signature and a highlight of many pay-per-view events.

The X-Division helped cement TNA’s reputation among hardcore fans, even during times when storylines or creative direction may have faltered. And it wasn’t just about spot-heavy matches. TNA used the division to cultivate legitimate stars.

One of its most successful products was Samoa Joe.

Though already a top performer and former world champion in Ring of Honor, Samoa Joe’s TNA run took his career to new heights.

He debuted with a dominant, months-long undefeated streak and quickly became one of the company’s biggest draws.

His hard-hitting, MMA-influenced style stood out in a landscape filled with theatrics and gimmicks. Joe would eventually capture the TNA World Heavyweight Championship, solidifying his place as a cornerstone of the promotion.

Years later, Samoa Joe continues to impress audiences, now performing for AEW, proof that the talent nurtured in TNA still has a lasting impact on the modern wrestling world.

Why TNA’s Monday Night War Strategy Collapsed

By the late 2000s, TNA had firmly established itself as a strong alternative to WWE.

With monthly pay-per-views and its Impact! television show enjoying consistent ratings on Thursday nights, the promotion had carved out a loyal following. It wasn’t on WWE’s level in terms of global reach, but it had a unique identity, a deep roster, and momentum on its side.

But in 2010, that all changed.

Driven by ambition, and perhaps a desire to replicate the success of the original Monday Night Wars between WWE and WCW, TNA president Dixie Carter made a bold and ultimately catastrophic decision to move Impact! to Monday nights, directly opposing WWE’s flagship show, Monday Night Raw.

To spearhead this move, Carter brought in two of the most iconic figures from the original Monday Night War era, Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff. Both men had been instrumental in WCW’s brief dominance in the late ‘90s, and their arrival in TNA was meant to signal a new era, one with bigger stars, more drama, and the audacious goal of toppling WWE’s dominance.

But unlike WCW in 1996, TNA didn’t have Ted Turner’s billions, a deep-pocketed network backing, or a clear strategy to win over WWE’s mainstream audience.

Their first Monday night episode aired on January 4, 2010. In fairness, it showed promise.

The show featured an influx of major names, many with WWE pasts, including Jeff Hardy, Ric Flair, Scott Hall, Sean Waltman, and even the debut of Rob Van Dam. The curiosity factor was high, and the broadcast drew an impressive 2.2 million average viewers.

However, that same night, WWE’s Raw, headlined by the return of Bret Hart after a 12-year absence, pulled in a staggering 5.6 million viewers.

The writing was on the wall. Despite the initial buzz, TNA failed to sustain the momentum.

Fans grew frustrated with the creative direction, over-reliance on aging stars, and the diminishing role of homegrown talents like AJ Styles and Samoa Joe. Rather than feel like a modern alternative, Impact! began to resemble a nostalgia-driven rerun of WCW’s final years.

By May 2010, just five months after the bold leap, TNA quietly moved Impact! back to its familiar Thursday night slot.

The experiment had failed, and the so-called "Monday Night War 2.0" was over before it truly began.

On an episode of My World podcast, Jeff Jarrett reflected on the chaos when Hogan arrived in 2009.

"I really look at TNA, from 2002 until the day Hulk Hogan was hired. The day Hulk got signed, the world changed and I knew it then. Did I know it was going to take the turns that it did? No way. I had some delusional optimism then and it continued."

In trying to beat WWE at its own game, TNA had lost focus on what had made it special in the first place. The fallout from this misstep would linger for years, marking the beginning of a long, uneven road ahead.

Dixie Carter’s Leadership Missteps That Cost TNA

Few figures are more closely associated with the rise and fall of TNA Wrestling than Dixie Carter.

For many years, she was the face of the company, first behind the scenes and eventually on-screen. As the promotion’s president, Carter initially offered a fresh and hopeful vision for a company aiming to compete on a national scale. But over time, her leadership would come under intense scrutiny from fans, talent, and industry insiders alike.

One of TNA’s greatest early achievements was how it elevated women’s wrestling long before WWE caught up.

The Knockouts division was innovative, diverse, and treated with respect. Angelina Love, a six-time Knockouts World Champion and one of the division’s biggest stars, once took pride in the way TNA centered women in major storylines.

But that pride eventually gave way to disillusionment.

"I’ve done a lot of interviews where I’ve talked about Dixie. At first, it seemed like a cool concept, but then it turned into a disastrous thing," Love told Pro Wrestling Stories in 2022.

"Once different people entered the company and started getting into her ear—she just changed. She wasn’t the warm, welcoming person that we used to be able to talk to and confide in. She ended up putting herself on every other segment on the show, and some of the girls were being taken off. It was just a disaster. Plus, she lost our Spike TV deal for us, and that was devastating. We all thought we were [done for] when that happened."

Her longtime tag partner, Velvet Sky, echoed those sentiments in a pointed tweet directed at wrestling journalist Dave Meltzer in 2018. Meltzer had claimed Spike TV cut ties with TNA due to Vince Russo’s involvement with creative.

"Spike canceled because they got tired of Dixie Carter. She’s the one who ruined TNA for all of us. They may have not been crazy about Russo, but Dixie is to blame."

Ironically, both Sky and Love had worked closely with Russo on their hugely successful Beautiful People gimmick, one of the Knockouts division’s most iconic acts.

At its peak, the division was light-years ahead of WWE’s portrayal of female talent, offering compelling characters and real storylines in a time when "Divas" were treated as little more than filler content.

But Russo’s controversial presence behind the scenes remained a sore spot for fans and critics. He’d been involved creatively since the promotion’s earliest years, minus a few hiatuses, and was often associated with the chaotic, overly scripted, and sometimes nonsensical booking decisions that frustrated loyal viewers.

"Fire Russo" chants were common in arenas by 2007, especially during bizarre gimmick matches or storylines that derailed otherwise solid shows.

By 2013, the cracks were widening. Momentum was fading, ratings were slipping, and backstage morale reportedly deteriorated.

The final blow came in 2015, when TNA lost its long-standing television deal with Spike TV, a devastating setback that cast serious doubt on the company’s survival. Without a major broadcast partner, the company was left adrift.

In a last-ditch effort to stabilize the ship, TNA brought in musician and wrestling enthusiast Billy Corgan, best known as the frontman of Smashing Pumpkins.

Corgan joined in 2015, initially taking on a creative role before briefly becoming company president. But internal conflict, financial instability, and legal disputes marred his tenure. By early 2017, TNA was sold to Anthem Sports & Entertainment.

TNA Wrestling, as fans knew it, was no more. In its place rose Impact Wrestling, a rebranded effort to move forward from a turbulent legacy.

Despite all the highs and lows, TNA left a lasting mark on the industry. From revolutionary matches and breakout stars to chaotic mismanagement and unrealized potential, the promotion’s journey was truly Total Nonstop Action.

Making an Impact: The Rebirth of a Wrestling Brand

By the mid-2010s, TNA Wrestling had become synonymous with behind-the-scenes chaos, including leadership changes, creative instability, and an ever-shifting roster.

Yet amid all the noise, the company was still capable of moments of brilliance that reminded fans why they tuned in in the first place.

In 2016, just before a major creative shakeup, TNA made one of its most influential contributions to modern pro wrestling: the birth of the cinematic match.

Dubbed "The Final Deletion," the bizarre, otherworldly showdown between Matt Hardy and his brother Jeff (as “Broken” Matt and “Brother Nero”) wasn’t held in a ring in front of fans, but rather filmed on location at Matt Hardy’s sprawling North Carolina compound.

The match featured drones, fireworks, outrageous editing, and a surreal, almost soap opera-like tone. While similar pre-filmed segments had been attempted in wrestling before, Final Deletion took things to a new level – and fans couldn’t stop talking about it.

The match went viral. It broke through wrestling fandom into the broader pop culture space. And just like that, TNA had once again changed the game. WWE, AEW, and others would later adopt the concept, especially during the pandemic era, when cinematic storytelling became a necessary pivot.

Despite this innovation, leadership turbulence continued.

In late 2016, wrestling journalist Wade Keller summarized the uncertainty in a piece for PWTorch.com.

"TNA had a solid year on air but turmoil behind the scenes. I’m curious to see the changes in the product starting tomorrow night, now without Billy Corgan or Dave Lagana on the creative team. It’s too early to tell how this will affect TNA’s product, the relationship and pay of the wrestlers, the potential changes in who gets pushed on TV, and, of course, the product’s overall creative direction and tone. Stay tuned."

Not long after, the promotion merged temporarily with Jeff Jarrett’s Global Force Wrestling (GFW), in yet another attempt to reinvent itself.

Between spring and fall 2017, Impact and GFW operated as one. The partnership culminated in a high-stakes world title unification match between Bobby Lashley and Alberto El Patrón at Slammiversary XV.

The show was critically well-received, but internal and legal issues caused the GFW merger to unravel before the year ended.

Heading into 2018, many fans had written Impact off as a fading brand. But a major change was coming.

That January, Impact Wrestling announced that Don Callis and Scott D’Amore would take over the day-to-day operations of the company as executive vice presidents. Both were respected veterans in the industry – Callis as a former WWE and NJPW commentator, and D’Amore as a long-time producer, booker, and talent scout.

The shift in leadership paid immediate dividends. Under Callis and D’Amore, Impact began producing a consistent run of critically acclaimed pay-per-views. Gone were the bloated storylines and erratic booking of the past. Instead, the company focused on compelling rivalries, standout in-ring action, and elevating fresh talent alongside trusted veterans.

Impact Wrestling was no longer trying to be "the next WWE."

It was content carving its own path – and fans were beginning to appreciate that.

Thriving, Not Surviving: Impact Wrestling’s Revival and Resilience

While many predicted that TNA – now Impact Wrestling – would fade into obscurity, the promotion has instead become a remarkable story of persistence, reinvention, and quiet influence across the modern wrestling landscape.

Impact embraced collaboration, innovation, and legacy-building – and it’s paying off.

During the pandemic, Impact took bold steps to stay relevant in an industry that had slowed to a crawl.

One of its most significant moves was partnering with All Elite Wrestling (AEW). This cross-promotional effort showcased top-tier talent from both companies and gave fans dream matches they never thought possible.

The most high-profile moment came in April 2021, when AEW World Champion Kenny Omega defeated Impact World Champion Rich Swann in a winner-takes-all title match at Rebellion.

Omega’s victory brought even more eyes to Impact Wrestling, legitimizing the promotion in the eyes of new fans while reinforcing its value as a brand with top-tier performers.

AEW President Tony Khan even appeared on Impact Wrestling, first via tongue-in-cheek "paid advertisement" segments, then in person, signaling an unprecedented level of cooperation between rival U.S. wrestling companies.

But perhaps the most shocking and symbolic moment of Impact’s modern era came in January 2022, when Mickie James, the reigning Knockouts World Champion, entered the WWE Royal Rumble.

Not only did she walk out to her Impact theme music, but she wore the Knockouts title proudly around her waist. In an industry notorious for protecting its brand image, WWE acknowledging a reigning Impact champion was historic and unthinkable just a few years prior. For long-time Impact loyalists, it was a surreal and satisfying payoff.

In a 2022 interview with PWInsider, executive Scott D’Amore emphasized how the modern Impact product was built on a tireless, collaborative effort across the board:

"Night after night, week after week, I think our talent roster has stepped up. We have a great group that’s meshed together talent-wise. The collaboration between talent and the front office, the administration, whatever you want to call it, has been next level. From Creative to Talent Relations to Production to the entire support network of Anthem Sports, it’s been a great collaborative effort. I’m really proud of where we are right now."

Impact Wrestling didn’t just survive – it evolved.

A perfect example of this evolution was the 2022 Slammiversary pay-per-view, celebrating 20 years of TNA/Impact history.

The show was a love letter to the promotion’s legacy. The main event between Josh Alexander and Eric Young included tributes to some of the company’s most iconic figures, with the wrestlers using signature moves and finishers associated with legends like Jeff Jarrett, Christopher Daniels, Kurt Angle, and Abyss.

Even as Impact looks to the future, it refuses to ignore the legends and missteps that shaped its path. By blending respect for its storied past with a commitment to producing high-quality, forward-thinking wrestling, Impact Wrestling has finally carved out its identity, not as a WWE rival, but as a promotion that values creativity, resilience, and long-term storytelling.

The Return of TNA: The 2024 Rebrand, A Legacy Reborn

In a bold move few anticipated, Impact Wrestling officially resurrected the TNA Wrestling name in early 2024, reclaiming the three letters that once stood for both innovation and chaos.

This wasn’t mere nostalgia; it was a reinvention of purpose. TNA shed the punchline image to become a battle-tested brand, poised to write a new chapter on the foundation it fought so hard to preserve.

The rebrand extended beyond paint and logos. An energized roster, upgraded production values, and a renewed focus on blending hungry rising stars with trusted veterans reshaped the promotion’s identity.

Talent such as Josh Alexander, Jordynne Grace, Speedball Mike Bailey, and Moose carried the standard forward, while returning icons like Eric Young and Frankie Kazarian reminded fans of TNA’s storied lineage.

By 2025, TNA felt like its strongest self: confident, focused, and embracing its quirks. Rather than chase viral moments or market share, it carved out a reputation as wrestling’s most consistent, creatively liberated brand.

Tighter shows, cohesive booking, and an international talent pipeline with WWE/NXT, NJPW, AAA, and GCW enriched both weekly TV and marquee pay-per-views.

Hard to Kill and Rebellion in 2024 drew acclaim for storytelling, athleticism, and emotional stakes. And at Bound for Glory in October 2025, the promotion’s flagship showcase continued that legacy, delivering standout performances that reaffirmed TNA’s enduring promise.

The revival of the TNA name is more than symbolic. It marks the evolution of a company that weathered missteps and chaos to emerge resilient and mature, proving that survival, adaptation, and creative courage can yield lasting triumph in wrestling’s high-stakes arena.

These stories may also interest you:

• Christian and the Bizarre Deal Between WWE and TNA in 2012
• Samoa Joe, Kevin Nash, and their Fight Over Scott Hall
• Kurt Angle and Samoa Joe: Untold Secret Behind TNA MMA Match

Can’t get enough pro wrestling history in your life? Sign up to unlock ten pro wrestling stories curated uniquely for YOU, plus subscriber-exclusive content. A special gift from us awaits after signing up!

Want More? Choose another story!

Be sure to follow us on Facebook, X/Twitter, Instagram, Threads, YouTube, TikTok, and Flipboard!

---

Pro Wrestling Stories is committed to accurate, unbiased wrestling content rigorously fact-checked and verified by our team of researchers and editors. Any inaccuracies are quickly corrected, with updates timestamped in the article's byline header.

Got a correction, tip, or story idea for Pro Wrestling Stories? Contact us! Learn about our editorial standards here. Ever wanted to learn more about the people behind Pro Wrestling Stories? Meet our team of authors!

---

ProWrestlingStories.com participates in affiliate marketing programs. This post may contain affiliate links, meaning we may earn commissions at no extra cost to our readers. This supports our mission to deliver free content for you to enjoy!

---