George The Animal Steele: A Teacher’s Secret Life as a Wrestler

George The Animal Steele, the former WWE wrestler who passed away at 79 on February 16th, 2017, led a double life.

Before his death, he revealed how he became “The Animal,” his secret life, and the story behind his “fetish” for turnbuckles (and how he legitimately almost killed a wrestler with its stuffing)!

Before his passing, professional wrestler George The Animal Steele opened up about his secret life on the side.
Before his passing, professional wrestler George The Animal Steele opened up about his secret life on the side.

"Everything that happened with me happened by accident. One of the things I’m always asked about is, ‘Why did you have a fetish for turnbuckles?’"

– George The Animal Steele


The Other Teachers Didn’t Know

George The Animal Steele with his sidekick, "Mine."
George The Animal Steele with his sidekick, “Mine.” [Photo Credit: WWE]
In an interview on Busted Open Radio in 2013, George The Animal Steele opened up about leading a double life as a wrestler and a teacher and how he became "The Animal" in wrestling.

"When I was wrestling in New York or the North East, [students and colleagues] didn’t know that back in Michigan."

Jim Myers: High School Teacher, Amateur Wrestling Coach, Football Coach, Professional Wrestler?

Jim Myers (George the Animal Steele) leaves a legacy that reaches far beyond the squared circle.
Jim Myers (George the Animal Steele) leaves a legacy that reaches far beyond the squared circle.

After earning a bachelor of science degree from Michigan State University and a master’s degree from Central Michigan University, the real-life Jim Myers became a teacher, amateur wrestling coach, and football coach at Madison High School in Madison Heights, Michigan. There he would eventually become a member of the Michigan Coaches Hall of Fame.

"Back in Michigan, I was wearing a mask, so, you know, the students really never knew what was going on. Occasionally, a student from the North East would move into the Madison Heights area and say, ‘Is that you? You’re a wrestler; you’re George Steele!’ And I’d simply look at him and say, ‘Do you really think I’m that ugly?’"

High School Names Stadium After George the Animal Steele

Jim Myers (George The Animal Steele) outside Jim Myers Stadium at Madison High School in Madison, Michigan. The school dedicated the stadium to him after his many years of service.
Jim Myers (George The Animal Steele) outside Jim Myers Stadium at Madison High School in Madison, Michigan. The school dedicated the stadium to him after his many years of service.

It was a proud moment for the late Jim Myers when Madison High School dedicated the football field in his name.

He was a long-time teacher, amateur wrestling coach, and football coach at the school.

Becoming "The Animal"

Early in his career, George Steele, a school teacher, donned a mask and wrestled as The Student.
Early in his career, George Steele, a school teacher, donned a mask and wrestled as “The Student.”

"I was wrestling around Michigan [where I lived] with a mask on. I was spotted and taken into Pittsburgh,” Myers explained. And they didn’t want me to use my mask!”

“I did not want to use my real name because of teaching and coaching. So Johnny DeFazio, one of the guys there, said, ‘Well, this is the Steel City, let’s call him Jim Steele.’ I didn’t like the ‘Jim.’ Somebody else said, George. So George Steele it was. I was about 46 years old."

"Back in the black and white TV days in ’67, in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, they had their wrestling promotion in a studio – channel 11 studio.

"They would put plywood around the outside of the ring, sit people in front of it. Now the plywood was painted black, and they had faces on it, so it made the crowd look bigger. I mean, we’re talking about old, old wrestling. Vince McMahon would die if they did that today.

"They would give away a gift now and then to get fans to come there for the promotion. This particular Saturday afternoon, they gave away couch pillows. Satin couch pillows from the ’60s packed real tight.

"So we’re in the match, and somebody got mad at me, I think it was a lady, and she threw her pillow at me. So what am I gonna do? If I sit on it, it’s going to be boring. If I throw it back, I’m gonna get bombed with 300 of them. So I took it, and I bit it. And it exploded! So I started throwing the stuffing up in the air, and it came down and stuck."

Almost Killing a Wrestler with Turnbuckle Stuffing

George The Animal Steele loved his turnbuckles!
George The Animal Steele loved his turnbuckles! [Photo Credit: WWE]
George Steele continued, "The stuffing was lighter than air, so it stuck in my hair, I looked like the abominable snowman. And then I put it over my opponent’s head and started choking him. When I pulled it off, because the stuffing was lighter than air, it almost killed him."

"When I got to the dressing room, wrestlers, being like wrestlers were back then, all laughed and said, ‘Gee, you almost killed that one. If you get someone to throw a pillow sometime, that was really exciting!’"

In a spontaneous, reactive moment in the ring, "The Animal" was born, a gimmick George Steele would use for the rest of his career.

"About three weeks later," Steele continued, "I was wrestling Chief Jay Strongbow. He always had exciting matches [but] our match was just boring; it was not working. How do you have a boring match with him? Anyhow, I looked over at the turnbuckle, I went over, and there was an old Everlast turnbuckle. I took a bite out of it, tore his head, rubbed it in his face, and ran his head into the turnbuckle.

"From kind of a flat match, we had a riot. So from then on, the turnbuckles did become a bit of a fetish…"

Separating "The Animal" from Home Life

Jim Myers (George The Animal Steele).
Jim Myers (George The Animal Steele).

So how could someone as intelligent as Jim Meyers create someone the complete opposite as George The Animal Steele?

"Let’s say I was in the main event at Madison Square Garden on a Saturday night. I come home Sunday, and I’m gonna be on the football field on Monday with a whistle around my neck. My wife had this process of we have to get George in the box and get Jim OUT of the box. And that mentally had to happen cause it was a huge swing in personalities."

“It Happened By the Fans”

George The Animal Steele along with legendary wrestling manager and wrestler Captain Lou Albano.
George The Animal Steele along with legendary wrestling manager and wrestler Captain Lou Albano. [Photo Credit: WWE]
George The Animal Steele talked about how it was the fans who created what he was:

"When I first came to New York, Boston, Philadelphia, the WWWF, I did my own interviews. And I was very articulate.

“The first year I was in there, they called me, I think it was George ‘The Destroyer’ Steele. And the next time, it was George ‘The Bruiser’ Steele. I didn’t like either one of them. But the people, because of the hair, the body; I was pretty vicious-looking, started calling me an animal.

“I’d get on the microphone using my intelligence and say, ‘I’m not an animal, I’m a people!’

"As soon as I did that, the more they would call me The Animal. And finally, about the third or fourth year, the WWF picked up on The Animal thing. So that was not created; it just happened by the fans. The fans are the greatest creation team."

Legacy of Jim Myers (George The Animal Steele)

The legacy of Jim Myers, also known as George The Animal Steele, continues to be remembered in the world of professional wrestling and beyond.
The legacy of Jim Myers, also known as George The Animal Steele, continues to be remembered in the world of professional wrestling and beyond. [Photo Credit: WWE.]
Although he was never a champion or the biggest act in WWE or wherever he performed, George The Animal Steele was still highly recognized and popular among wrestling fans during the 1970s and ’80s.

With his decades-long career, he wrestled alongside some of the best to lace up a pair of wrestling boots.

Steele stayed active in professional wrestling after retiring from active competition due to Crohn’s Disease in 1988. He also significantly impacted his students as a high school teacher and coach at Madison High School in Michigan until he tragically passed away on February 16th, 2017, at 79, due to kidney failure.

Jim Myers continues to be remembered in the world of professional wrestling and beyond.

These stories may also interest you:

Want More? Choose another story!

Be sure to follow us on Facebook, X/Twitter, Instagram, Threads, YouTube, TikTok, and Flipboard!
Pro Wrestling Stories is committed to accurate, unbiased wrestling content rigorously fact-checked and verified by our team of researchers and editors. Any inaccuracies are quickly corrected, with updates timestamped in the article's byline header.
Got a correction, tip, or story idea for Pro Wrestling Stories? Contact us! Learn about our editorial standards here.

This post may contain affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us provide free content for you to enjoy!

https://bit.ly/jpzarkamusic

JP Zarka founded Pro Wrestling Stories in 2015 and is the creative force behind the website as editor-in-chief. From 2018-19, he was the podcast host and producer for The Genius Cast with Lanny Poffo, brother of WWE legend Macho Man Randy Savage. His diverse career includes work as an elementary school teacher, assistant principal, and musician, notably as a singer-songwriter with the London-based band Sterling Avenue. Zarka has appeared on TV programs like “Autopsy: The Last Hours of” on Reelz (U.S.) and Channel 5 (U.K.) and has contributed research for programming on ITV and BBC.