Author: During a brawl inside a densely-filled ring in 2005, JBL legitimately laid a beating on The Blue Meanie, leaving his face bloodied in the aftermath. Even though the ring was filled with dozens of bodies, the state Blue Meanie was in just couldn’t be ignored.
The Blue Meanie vs. JBL – What Was Going On?
Four years after the original ECW folded in 2001, WWE had a reunion pay-per-view entitled ECW One Night Stand 2005. The card featured a slew of ECW Originals, and it was a night to remember for the ECW diehards. Ironically, though, on a show that heavily featured ECW stars, it was a WWE star that created the headlines.
On the Talk is Jericho podcast, Blue Meanie explained the reasons behind JBL’s heat with him, which led to the attack:
"I did an interview when I left WWE. I said, ‘I had a great time in WWE. I saw the world. I got paid to see the world on Vince McMahon’s dime.’ I thanked WWE. I was like, ‘The only thing is, JBL was kind of an asshole.’
During my whole tenure there [in WWE] from ’98 to 2000, it was like, I don’t want to say, like, hazing, but bullying. Whether it would be shots in a match or we’d be on a plane, and he’s telling a story about some fat fuck, you know he’s referencing you."
Word had gotten out to JBL that The Blue Meanie mentioned he was a bully. This obviously lit a fire in Bradshaw’s eyes, and when it was time to brawl at the end of the pay-per-view, JBL took this as an opportunity to pay him back. Meanie goes into detail about what transpired:
"I felt this punch right on my scar [a recent injury from wrestling], and I went, ‘What the hell?’ I turned around; there was JBL. He started throwing shots. He did the hockey thing, pulling my shirt over my face [and] began throwing live rounds. He [had] a fistful of rings, so I was like, ‘I ain’t going to take this!’, so I snatched a headlock as much as I could on a 6’6" man, and I started throwing punches back. We kind of got pulled apart.
[When I went] to the back and Johnny Ace met me at the curtain, he went, ‘What the hell was that?’ I was like, ‘What? JBL shot on me!’ He was like, ‘No, no- Who told you [that] you could blade?’ I was like, ‘I didn’t!’ He was like, ‘What?’
At this point, I gave him the elevator pitch of the heat that [JBL and I] had. He was like, ‘That’s unacceptable. We don’t do that here. Blah, blah, blah.’ And I walked further into the ‘Gorilla’ position, and there was JBL…
He said, ‘You were talking about me on the Internet.’
I was like, ‘Crap, dude, was I wrong? You’re having a hard time proving me wrong!’
So, long story short, WWE did the right thing. They stitched me up and doubled my pay for that night!"
JBL Shares His Side of the Story
In an interview with WWE.com, JBL shared his side of the story and his reasoning behind the attack on Blue Meanie:
"Before the brawl at the end of the pay-per-view, [Blue Meanie] started cutting a shoot promo on me, saying I’m the reason he got fired and the only reason I got to where I am was because I suck Vince McMahon’s dick. I was incredulous. I thought there’s no way he could really mean this.
So I got to work with him at the end, and here we are, trying to give the fans a great finish [to the pay-per-view] when we begin to lock horns in the melee. But he’s basically not even acknowledging my presence. Now I might have caught him snug with a shot, but then he started throwing back heavy punches, including a body shot. So make no mistake, I club him back to make sure he knows I’m not playing, and I think I got him with a shot over the eye and one near the forehead and apparently opened him up a little.
Backstage I asked him if he wanted to finish it right then and there. He told me it’s all a show and that he didn’t want to fight. And he pretty much ran off."
Blue Meanie later commented:
"To me, it’s just really sad. JBL is supposed to be one of the top guys. He’s supposed to lead by example, not by fear."
It was an ugly situation all around and was serious enough that Blue Meanie considered suing. Had it not been for WWE offering him a short-term contract and an opportunity to make some money with JBL afterward, he just might have done it.
Blue Meanie Gets His Revenge
On a July 7th, 2005 episode of SmackDown, a tall order of rough justice was served.
In a match where JBL faced off against The Blue Meanie, Meanie picked up the victory via help from Batista. But before the pin, it was Blue Meanie’s partner in crime with the bWo, Stevie Richards, making headlines delivering one of the hardest-to-watch chair shots to JBL’s head. It was a shot thrown so hard you could see the pure anger behind it. Stevie was sticking up for his friend here by delivering a well-deserved receipt to the bully.
The Aftermath
The majority of the time, the fallout after events such as these end up pretty positive. This situation was no different.
In 2015, The Blue Meanie gave an update on his relationship with JBL:
"From that ugly incident to now, [JBL and I are] Twitter buddies," Blue Meanie began. "Yeah, you can make friends with somebody once you make money with them. The coup de grâce was this last year he tried to get me in the Royal Rumble since it was in Philadelphia. He lobbied because I had just done ECW Unreleased Volume 3 for WWE [and] what better way to announce the DVD than getting an ECW Original in Philadelphia coming to the ring. It came down to that Friday before, but in the end, they picked Bubba [Dudley] instead of me. I love Bubba, and I marked out seeing Bubba come out, too!"
The Blue Meanie was only two days out from a Royal Rumble appearance before WWE decided to go with Bubba Ray, but JBL nearly got him there!
A happy ending to an otherwise rough story.
These stories may also interest you:
- Mauro Ranallo, JBL, and the Culture of Veteran Hazing in the WWE
- Wrestlers’ Court – Bizarre Tales from the WWE Locker Room
- Hornswoggle – The Unlikely Backstage Bully!
Can’t get enough pro wrestling history in your life? Sign up to unlock ten pro wrestling stories curated uniquely for YOU, plus subscriber-exclusive content. A special gift from us awaits after signing up!
Want More? Choose another story!
Be sure to follow us on Facebook, X/Twitter, Instagram, Threads, YouTube, TikTok, and Flipboard!
Pro Wrestling Stories is committed to accurate, unbiased wrestling content rigorously fact-checked and verified by our team of researchers and editors. Any inaccuracies are quickly corrected, with updates timestamped in the article's byline header.
Got a correction, tip, or story idea for Pro Wrestling Stories? Contact us! Learn about our editorial standards here.
This post may contain affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us provide free content for you to enjoy!
