Todd Pettengill: Secret Behind His Rise and Fall in WWE

Todd Pettengill is no stranger to you if you watched the WWF during the "New Generation Era" between 1993 and 1997. He played a prominent on-air role as a backstage interviewer and host to programs such as WWF Mania, WWF Blast-Off, WWF LiveWire, and WWF Action Zone. This is the story of his rise and fall in WWE!

The rise and fall of Todd Pettengill in WWE.
The rise and fall of Todd Pettengill in WWE.

Todd Pettengill – The Face of WWE’s New Generation Era

As a kid, I would forward to Saturday mornings, when I would watch Pettengill recap the very best WWF moments of the week alongside Macho Man Randy Savage, Stephanie Wiand, and Sunny on USA’s WWF Mania at 10 am EST. This show, alongside the TV series Weird Science, packed a good one-two punch for many a Saturday morning for me (and many others, I’m sure)!

Todd’s quirky and warm personality fit perfectly with the product’s tone back then and was a big part of many memorable moments during that era. How can one forget him hanging out in the audience at Caesars Palace in Las Vegas while wearing sunglasses, a toga, and a headband with fake golden leaves glued onto the sides at WrestleMania 9?

Or how about the time Todd Pettengill and Stephanie Wiand gave away a house to a lucky fan during the inaugural In Your House pay-per-view?

You better believe I was one of the fans who sent in a postcard with my details, watching live, hoping with bated breath that I would win! Unfortunately, I did not, but one lucky eleven-year-old fan named Matt Pompaselli did.

For those wondering, he ended up selling his Florida home about six months after he won it to the tune of $175,000. Not a bad investment for an eleven-year-old!

Before Todd Pettengill played a role in WWF fans’ lives, he got a start in the entertainment industry at the young age of thirteen.

"My mom just wanted me to have a job," Pettengill opens up to James Delow of the weekly WWE fancast, Gorilla Position. "You know, at thirteen, apparently, it was important that I start to work right away! I thought it might have been a little bit early, but she knew a guy at a local radio station where I grew up in upstate New York, and I went over and fell in love with it.

"They paid me in records because I was too young to earn money," Pettengill continued. "I wasn’t even old enough to have working papers yet! My voice changed at a very young age. I always had a deeper voice, so when people listened, they always thought that I was older. When they would come to the radio station or something to meet me, they were like, ‘You’re only a kid!’

"I would ride my bike over to the radio station after school and work, and then my dad would come and pick me up because it was dark. We’d put the bike in the back and go home. That’s how it started, and that was many, many years ago! You know, I found a love. They say once you find something you really love to do, you’re not working a day in your life."

His outgoing personality is what helped Pettengill gravitate towards radio.

By his own admission, he was the class clown, and it was "either radio or end up in jail" for him, and he preferred the former!

"Radio became a way for me to express this comedy and energy, and man, after a while, they paid you to do it, which is even cooler!"

How Todd Pettengill Got Involved With the WWE

Todd Pettengill at WrestleMania IX
Todd Pettengill at WrestleMania IX, his first pay-per-view with the company [Photo: Scott’s Blog of Doom!]
Right out of high school, Todd moved to Albany, New York, where he got a job at WFLY radio station where he would do the morning show on ‘Fly 92’ for seven years.

To this day, his breakfast radio show is the highest-rated in Albany history.

In ’91, an opportunity came up for him to do radio in New York City, and by age 25, he became the youngest breakfast radio show host in New York City. This is where he has worked ever since. It was around this time Vince McMahon first took notice of him.

"Vince McMahon was listening to my radio show and just called and said, ‘Hey, you’re kind of funny. You’re kind of a weird guy. What do you think about coming up here and maybe having an interview?’"

Vince was looking for a replacement for Sean Mooney, who had chosen not to renew his contract with the company.

"I said, ‘Well, I really don’t know anything about wrestling…’

"Vince responded, ‘Perfect!’"

Vince wanted somebody with an outsider’s point of view who wouldn’t bring misconceptions to the role, and Todd was up for the challenge.

"The first person I met was Linda McMahon. She was the one who was running the business day-to-day.

“I had a nice meeting with Linda, and she said, ‘Alright, well, Vince would like to see you in one of the studios.’

“I went into a studio, and there was Vince, not quite as big as he is now but a big and intimidating figure nonetheless, and he threw me a bottle of water and said, ‘Sell it to me!’ So I did.

"I could talk about anything. You know, ‘This is the most unbelievable water! It’s fresh; it’ll soothe you! You can pour it on your feet if you’re in the desert…’

“I went through this whole thing, and he goes, ‘That’s unbelievable! Let’s try this!’ And that’s how it all started."

"Here’s a story I have never told publicly about Vince McMahon."

Todd Pettengill and Vince McMahon in '95
Todd Pettengill and Vince McMahon in ’95

After the interview, Vince McMahon was assumed to have left the building. Pettengill went to use the bathroom when he noticed somebody in one of the stalls.

"There was a fella in the stall who had clearly been doing some work! It was not a pleasant odor. So I, being me, said, ‘Hey, how about a courtesy flush!’

"I heard this laugh behind the stall, and it was Vince. When he came out, I was like, ‘Well, I didn’t get this job!’ and he goes, ‘That’s hysterical! Now I gotta hire you!’"

Throughout Pettengill’s four years with the WWF, he continued working his radio show full-time in New York City while also fulfilling obligations to Vince McMahon, which included all pay-per-views and traveling to Stamford, Connecticut, two or three times a week (an hour and forty-five-minute journey each direction).

Describing his first WrestleMania, he said, "My very first pay-per-view I was wearing a toga at Caesars Palace. That’s where I broke in!"

He continued, "The pageantry that surrounds [WrestleMania] and the number of people that it takes to pull off something like that was just mind-boggling to me.

“It’s really like doing a football or baseball game where it’s forty cameras, sound trucks, producers in your ear- it’s a major production. The talent was just- those guys were just amazing to work with."

When Todd started with the company, he fit in with the process. He was used to working live on radio and pitching packages with a producer in his ear as the tape was rolling.

All of this was like muscle memory to him. But as WWF was new to him, he had to learn all the names, the timing for everybody, and how things worked in this different environment.

But throughout the process, there were many people behind-the-scenes who helped him out.

"Kevin Dunn, who is the executive producer over there, was absolutely amazing to me. Really really great.

“Another person I really enjoyed was Gorilla Monsoon. Gorilla and I were really good friends. The Macho Man Randy Savage when we did a show together, Ted DiBiase ‘The Million Dollar Man.’

“There were so many guys that, you know, Jim Ross, that sort of showed me the ropes. I loved Howard Finkel.

“All of these guys took the time to say, ‘Hey kid, come here. We’re going to do this; we’re going to do that.’ I loved it."

For being an outsider and not knowing much about the industry, it’s amazing how warm and welcoming everybody was.

A Day in the Life of Todd Pettengill in the WWE

Todd Pettengill and Macho Man Randy Savage on the set of WWF Mania which taped live Saturday mornings from Stamford, CT.
Todd Pettengill and Macho Man Randy Savage on the set of WWF Mania, which taped live Saturday mornings from Stamford, CT.

"I would get up at 2:30, quarter to three in the morning. I’d be in New York City by four o’clock. We’d do the radio show, and I’d be out of there by ten o’clock with a Town Car waiting for me to take me to Stamford.

“We’d go to Stamford, and we’d either do Mania, or Superstars, or Challenge, or there’s a segment taping for Raw. I’m happy to say I was on the first Raw, which was very cool.

“I would be there for four or five hours and then get back in the Town Car and head back to my home in New Jersey. I lived in Manhattan when I started, so the car would go there.

"You’d go to makeup, you’d go to a show, you’d knock out packages, sometimes there would be more sometimes there would be less, you’d do your voice-overs and then back in the car, and I’d come back and do it again two or three times a week.

“Keep in mind some of those shows were live, and when we did those shows on Saturday mornings, those shows were live too, and it was the same drill only I didn’t have to do the radio show first."

Sometimes pulling double duty with the radio station and working for Vince wasn’t always easy, particularly when Monday Night Raw started airing live on Monday nights.

"For the first Monday Night Raw, it was at the Manhattan Center, which was right around the block from me. Nobody knew what to expect.

“It was like, ‘What’s he doing? Monday Night Raw? This is unbelievable!’

“For me, it was like I have to do my radio show in the morning, I better sleep a little during the day, but there was no sleeping because you had all this nervous energy and you were doing it live."

Describing his memories of the first-ever Raw, "I don’t remember exactly what I did. I think I did a package somewhere, but it was live and really exciting!"

Working for Vince McMahon During the New Generation Era

'The New Generation Era' - WWF's roster in 1995.
"The New Generation Era" – The WWF roster in 1995.

While Todd Pettengill worked for the WWF, it was an interesting time for the company.

Although talents like Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, Razor Ramon (Scott Hall), and Diesel (Kevin Nash) came into their own, The Golden Era had passed, and from a business standpoint, WWF hadn’t hit the strides of the Attitude Era quite yet.

Describing what Vince was like to work with at the time and whether he was showing the pressures of the business being down, Pettengill said, "Vince was always the same. He was always kind, always welcoming, always the first guy to crack a joke.

“I always thought that he never really ever took himself too seriously. If he was performing, it was a totally different thing, but the day-to-day, human-to-human contact was just so genuine and so real that if you ever hear a story of Vince not being a good guy, it’s just not true.

“From my perspective, it was just fantastic. He was, like I said, very genuine and very welcoming. If I ever had a question, he was sure to say, ‘Hey, ask, don’t worry about it. There are no stupid questions.’ So he was amazing to work with."

"I think [Vince] got that I knew the business [with my radio background] or understood the business, but one of the things he said that I think I’ll never forget was, ‘Listen, television is movement. We gotta move. We gotta move. We gotta move, constantly, be moving. Change your angles; let’s do different things.

“Television is movement, and in my mind, WWE’s production is one of the best. It’s unbelievable, and that’s because of Vince. He hires great people, but it starts there [with him]. It really is unparalleled."

Working with “Sunny” Tammy Sytch

YouTube video

During his time with the company, Pettengill got to work with many colorful characters, from Macho Man Randy Savage, Doc Hendrix (Michael ‘PS’ Hayes), to Sunny (Tammy Sytch).

"Sunny was great. I mean, very self-deprecating, very entertaining, friendly. I think she was involved with one of the wrestlers at the time (Chris Candido), but she was great.

“We had a lot of laughs, and we did a couple of shows together as a matter of fact but just a terrific person."

Regarding whether or not he heard about the rumors of her and HBK, Todd replied, "At the time, there really wasn’t anything that I knew of. I certainly didn’t hear of it, but maybe not being there full time in the office helped me not hear that kind of stuff. I would sort of come in, do my taping, and then shoot back to Manhattan."

Related: "What Sunny Wants, Sunny Gets…" – The Sad, Sordid Relationship of Sunny (Tammy Sytch) and Skip (Chris Candido)

Best and Worst Memories in WWE, a Run-in with Scott Hall

Todd Pettengill and Stephanie Wiand give away a house to a lucky fan during the inaugural In Your House pay-per-view.
Todd Pettengill and Stephanie Wiand at the inaugural In Your House pay-per-view where WWE actually gave away a house. [Photo:]
In talking about some of his best and worst memories from his time with the company, Todd Pettengill stated, "WrestleMania 9 at Caesars Palace was unbelievable and is so hard to beat.

“The ‘In Your House’ broadcasts to me were awesome, too. Stephanie Wiand, who I did some of those with later on where we actually gave away a house. That was pretty cool! Things like that were very, very memorable.

"In regards to the worst, I don’t really have any bad memories, but I think the only thing I could say is one time I got yelled at by Razor Ramon (Scott Hall) because I had my hair long and I had some stubble.

“He goes, ‘Hey, Chico, somebody’s already got that gig!’

“I was like, ‘Yes, sir!’

“No real problem there, but I think one of the things that happened there for me was while I was working there, as sometimes happens in your life, you go through a little weight gain.

“I got kind of fat while I was on camera! I was heavy. At one point, I had a really bad ’90s mullet, too, and looking back on it, I’m going, ‘What were you thinking? Why would you do that?’ But I did it!"

Regrets About Leaving WWE Before the Attitude Era

Todd Pettengill interviews Shawn Michaels at SummerSlam 1997. This was Pettengill's last pay-per-view with the company.
Todd Pettengill interviews Shawn Michaels at SummerSlam 1997. This was Pettengill’s last pay-per-view with the company. [photo:]
During Todd’s time with the WWF, his interviews with the talent backstage placed so much importance on the matches, and he did such an incredible job selling what you saw on television. He made everything feel so important and must-see.

"If you’re not into it as an announcer," Pettengill explains, "how is it going to sell to the audience?

"It was as much of an adrenaline pump for me as it was to [the fans]. To have 50,000 people on their feet screaming and the cameras showing it with the lights and explosions going off- if you don’t feel that and those matches that were so big- I was fanning out at times. I was fanboying out because I was so into it.

“You do become a fan really quickly when you’re immersed in it, and you get to know these guys and see them. It was a great [experience]!"

Despite becoming a fan and enjoying every minute of his time with the company, his personal life was put on hold. He was balancing two jobs, and he hadn’t had a day off in almost six years.

"I was with [WWE] for almost six years, and the reason I stopped was that I used all of my vacation time with the radio station to travel to pay-per-views, so I didn’t have a vacation for about six years. But, the day-to-day with [WWE] was great."

Pettengill’s last event with the company was at SummerSlam ’97, which saw a championship match between Bret Hart and Undertaker and the infamous Intercontinental championship match between Owen Hart and Steve Austin, where Owen almost left Austin paralyzed after a botched pile driver.

Sean Coulthard (Michael Cole) stepped in as a replacement off of the recommendation of Pettengill.

Soon later was Survivor Series ’97 with the Montreal Screwjob, which saw the industry change and get propelled into high gear with the dawning of the Attitude Era.

The timing of Pettengill’s departure was just before things really took off with the company, but did he ever feel regret for the timing of his exit?

"I think, like anything else, the business is very cyclical. It has an ebb and a flow, and I was in an ebb period, but I didn’t feel like it was.

“When I saw it move in that direction, you know, part of me said, ‘Man, I would have had a great time doing this kind of stuff!’

“Then, part of me said, ‘Well, maybe for the radio show that wasn’t exactly the image- it got pretty heated for quite a while [on WWE TV during the Attitude Era]!

"One of the big things, and I don’t think I’ve ever talked about this either, was in my contract — a lot of the guys would like to touch you, pick you up.

“I remember the late-great Owen Hart one time picked me up! I had to have a talk with Vince, where I said, ‘Look, I can’t do this. There’s no touching.’

“If you ever looked down the road, there are not many announcers — it used to be where they would get picked up, and poor Mean Gene used to get picked up — but that all changed because I was worried about all that.

“Man, these guys could unintentionally take you out! That would be it! So that was one of the things that evolved.

"I think [leaving before the Attitude Era began] was sort of a double-edged sword for me because I said, ‘Man, this would have been a blast! This would have been fun!’ but it got for a while… it kind of got up to the line and maybe over it sometimes, but that’s where entertainment was going in the country. It was a mirror of the country at the time."

On whether he misses his WWE days, Todd Pettengill admitted, "I do. It was a blast. There was nothing like performing in front of a live crowd like that, and I will tell you that wrestling fans are unlike any other fans I know.

“They’re so loyal, and they still remember! There aren’t many businesses where you can interview somebody who stopped doing a job in 1997 and still hear what that guy has to say. That’s because wrestling fans, and I still get it on social media for the radio station and when I go out.

“‘I remember you from wrestling!’

Those fans are so loyal, and some of them are loyal because they hated me. You know, ‘That goofball!’ and, ‘That weirdo! He was terrible!’ Listen, love is love, whether it’s in the form of an insult or what, at least they remember!"

Todd Pettengill’s Return to WWE in 2013

Todd Pettengill returned to WWE in 2013 to host the 'Best of In Your House' DVD
Todd Pettengill returned to WWE in 2013 to host the ‘Best of In Your House’ DVD [photo:]
In 2013, Todd Pettengill was asked back to WWE Headquarters in Stamford, Connecticut, to host the Best of In Your House DVD release.

"It was like I never left.

"I saw camera guys like John McCall. I saw Jill, my makeup artist, some of the producers were the same. It was like Old Home Week, it really was.

“There were some new folks there too who we sort of just- one of the deals, since I was in radio, was that they used to always call me ‘One Take Todd,’ so I would say, ‘Just give me the points and alright let’s do it!’ and boom, knock it out.

“[The new producers] would always say, ‘Are you sure you don’t want to do it again?’ and I would be like, ‘No! We did it. We killed it! Come on, let’s go.’

“One of the cameramen remembered and said, ‘This is going to be a fast day. We have one of the best here, ‘One Take Todd!’

"I ended up saying, ‘Let’s run through things again’ because I didn’t want things to end at that point.

“When you’re doing that volume of content, you want to make sure it’s good, but you want it to feel natural, so I think if it’s so rehearsed, sometimes it comes off that way, so I like to just say, ‘Give me the points, let me know what I have to hit, and then let’s just do it. And if I make a mistake, well, guess what? I made a mistake; let’s keep rolling!’

“I always used to pride myself on trying to knock that stuff right out.

"[Going back to WWE] was great. I loved it; I loved seeing everybody again. I didn’t get to see any of the guys, obviously, because I was in the studio with their cardboard cutouts, but it was still a great time!" (laughs)

What is Todd Pettengill Up to Today?

Todd Pettengill on his last day with his
Todd Pettengill on the last day with his "Todd and Jayde in the Morning" co-workers, May 2019. [Photo: @ToddPettengill on Instagram]
Pettengill left WWE on great terms and keeps in touch with many within the business to this day.

He is still working in radio. Unfortunately, his morning show "Todd and Jayde in the Morning" alongside Jayde Donovan on New York’s WPLJ 95.5 radio station ended in May 2019 due to being bought out to become a Christian Contemporary station.

He is now spending time with his family and waiting for his next venture.

As for the age-old question of whether or not he thinks there would ever be a chance for him to return to WWE, Pettengill responded with a coy, "I’m far too old!"

As we’ve learned with WWE and Vince McMahon over the years, never say never!

You can keep up with the latest on Todd Pettengill via his Instagram account @ToddPettengill.

These stories may also interest you:

We have hundreds of great Pro Wrestling Stories, but of course, you can’t read them all today. Sign up to unlock ten pro wrestling stories curated uniquely for YOU, plus subscriber-exclusive content. A special gift from us awaits after signing up!

Want More? Choose another story!

Be sure to follow us on Facebook, X/Twitter, Instagram, Threads, YouTube, TikTok, and Flipboard!
Pro Wrestling Stories is committed to accurate, unbiased wrestling content rigorously fact-checked and verified by our team of researchers and editors. Any inaccuracies are quickly corrected, with updates timestamped in the article's byline header.
Got a correction, tip, or story idea for Pro Wrestling Stories? Contact us! Learn about our editorial standards here.

This post may contain affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us provide free content for you to enjoy!

JP Zarka founded Pro Wrestling Stories in 2015 and is the creative force behind the website as editor-in-chief. From 2018-19, he was the podcast host and producer for The Genius Cast with Lanny Poffo, brother of WWE legend Macho Man Randy Savage. His diverse career includes work as an elementary school teacher, assistant principal, and musician, notably as a singer-songwriter with the London-based band Sterling Avenue. Zarka has appeared on TV programs like “Autopsy: The Last Hours of” on Reelz (U.S.) and Channel 5 (U.K.) and has contributed research for programming on ITV and BBC.